EFL Cup · Round of 16
James Garner 34'
Hayden Hackney 45'
Thierno Barry 69'
HT 2:0
Dan Burn 88'
Thu, 29 Oct 2026, 19:45 (UK) · Hill Dickinson Stadium, Liverpool

Everton had far fewer shots than Newcastle but scored twice before the break and leaned on eight Jordan Pickford saves to protect the lead.

FN MOMThierno Barry8.5Decisive moment34' James Garner+0.8NEW −0.7

Everton 3-1 Newcastle: clinical finishing, eight saves

Key numbers

  • Shots 11 v 28: Everton scored three from far fewer
  • xG per shot 0.17, highest in 10 matches
  • Eight Pickford saves; only goal conceded in the 88th minute

Fewer shots, more goals

Everton won 3-1 despite being heavily outshot by Newcastle. They scored three times from 11 attempts, while the visitors needed 28 for a single goal. The gap in shot counts pointed one way and the scoreline the other, so finishing decided it at Hill Dickinson Stadium.

Everton's shots carried more weight

Everton's xG per shot was 0.17, well above their average of 0.09 across 10 matches this season. They took fewer shots than usual, which suggests they traded volume for quality. It was the highest xG per shot of those 10 matches, and it helps explain how three goals came from so few attempts.

Newcastle volume without reward

Newcastle's nine shots on target were the most in their 10 matches this season, yet they scored only once, through Dan Burn in the 88th minute. Their xG per shot was 0.08, which points to quantity over quality. Jordan Pickford made eight saves, so plenty of shots, little return was the story of their evening.

Two first-half goals set the tone

James Garner's goal in the 34th minute was worth +0.8 FN xPts to Everton, while Newcastle's FN xPts fell by −0.7, the largest combined change of the match. Hayden Hackney, a new addition to the starting XI, added the second just before the break. By the time Burn pulled one back, the three-goal margin was already in place.

FN MOM
Highest FN Score · our own pick by a published formula, not the official Player of the Match
Thierno Barry 8.5Dominant

He scored once, set up another, created three chances and won nine of 15 duels.

Everton's FN MOM earned most of his value in attack. He set up Hayden Hackney's goal in the 45th minute, then took Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall's pass to make it 3-0 in the 69th, so two of Everton's three goals ran through him. Winning nine of 15 duels gave Everton an outlet up front while Newcastle had the bulk of the shots.

Game state

1-02-03-03-1
Everton ahead 56 min · level 34 min · Newcastle ahead 0 min

FN xPts — what each moment was worth

How much each moment changed that team's expected points (win 3, draw 1). A goal's value is credited 70% to the scorer and 30% to the assist. The value next to a team code is what the same moment did to the other side's expected points; the decisive moment is the one with the largest combined change for both teams.

34' James Garner Goal · scorer +0.6 · assist Hayden Hackney +0.2 · NEW −0.7 +0.8
45' Hayden Hackney Goal · scorer +0.3 · assist Thierno Barry +0.2 · NEW −0.3 +0.5
69' Thierno Barry Goal · assist Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall · NEW 0.0 +0.1
88' Dan Burn Goal · assist Joe Willock · EVE 0.0 0.0

Knockout ties have no league points, so moments are weighed on a win-3/draw-1 scale only.

How FN Score and FN xPts work →

Match stats

EvertonNewcastle
44%Possession56%
1.88Expected goals (xG)2.17
0.17xG per shot0.08
11Shots28
5Shots on target9
45%Shots on target %32%
7Shots in box19
333Passes428
4Corners10
8Saves2
18Fouls15
5Yellow cards3
0Offsides1

Compared with usual

Everton

10 matches this season, all competitions baseline
This matchAvg
Goals31.3
Conceded10.9
xG1.881.3
xG against2.171.5high
Shots1115.4
On target55.4
Shots faced2812.7high
xG per shot0.170.09high
Possession44%50.2%
Passes333468.8
Corners45
Fouls188.4high

Newcastle

10 matches this season, all competitions baseline
This matchAvg
Goals11.6
Conceded31.6
xG2.171.2high
xG against1.881.7
Shots2813.7high
On target94high
Shots faced1116
xG per shot0.080.1
Possession56%52.9%
Passes428434.6
Corners105.7
Fouls1512.1

Timeline

  • 34' Goal James Garner competition goal #1 assist Hayden Hackney
  • 45' Goal Hayden Hackney competition goal #1 assist Thierno Barry
  • 45' Sub William Osula → Yoane Wissa
  • 45' Sub Harvey Barnes → Anthony Elanga
  • 45' Sub Jacob Ramsey → Joelinton
  • 60' Yellow Hayden Hackney
  • 65' Sub Hayden Hackney → Harrison Armstrong
  • 67' Sub Jacob Murphy → Bazoumana Touré
  • 69' Goal Thierno Barry competition goal #4 assist Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
  • 74' Yellow Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall
  • 76' Sub Tyrique George → Carlos Alcaraz
  • 76' Sub Tyler Dibling → Brennan Johnson
  • 81' Sub Nico González → Sean Steur
  • 81' Yellow Vitaliy Mykolenko
  • 81' Yellow Fabian Schär
  • 86' Sub Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall → Christian Nørgaard
  • 86' Sub Vitaliy Mykolenko → Ainsley Maitland-Niles
  • 88' Goal Dan Burn competition goal #1 assist Joe Willock
  • 89' Yellow Dan Burn
  • 89' Yellow Joelinton
  • 89' Yellow James Tarkowski
  • 89' Yellow Jordan Pickford

Category leaders

  • Key passesJoe Willock6
  • Duels wonThierno Barry9/15
  • DribblesBazoumana Touré2/4
  • Defensive actionsMerlin Röhl7
  • ShotsJacob Murphy4 (on target 1)
  • Fouls wonLewis Hall4
#Everton#Newcastle#EFL Cup#Thierno Barry#Hayden Hackney#Jordan Pickford

This review was written by AI from match data (API-Football). FN Score and FN xPts are calculated by Fulltime Note using a published formula.